User blog comment:DerpyandDawn/Character Of The Week - Voting Process/@comment-24382795-20150616035812

It's hard choosing between Amy and Sky, cause I have enjoyed them the most. But because Sky is more consistent, where as Amy, had two really bad seasons (TDAST2 and TDTB), I have to choose Sky.

But, I really enjoyed all three of these characters at one point. Amy is just amazing in TDAN and TDATW, and is in my opinion the most well deserved winner yet. Duncan was great in both TDWW and TDRTTI, where he had great interactions and plots, and was just overall enjoyable. However, as he competed in TDAST2 and TDTB, he has lowered on my rankings. Sky has been one of my favorite characters from the beginning. She has always been in my top 5 of all her seasons, as I have extremely enjoyed her. Her plots were great, and her interactions were spot on. I really like her plot so far for TDAN.