User blog:Epic~00/Top 16 S1 Contestants

Everyone seems to be doing this lately, I thought I would do the same, especially since Season 1 is beginning tomorrow. I'll try to not put these odds of these rankings too much in my favor. So, let's get right into it.

Leshawna


I thought that, hmm, about 15 other characters did something more interesting than Leshawna ever did. Tyman barely competing much was unfortunate, because even though I'm not the biggest fan of Leshawna, she had huge potential in this season if only she had been placed on the same team as Gwen and Heather. If you were to take her out of the season, nothing would change. She deserves to be low on all of these rankings. She's so uninteresting that it's hard to even talk about her.

Samey


This roleplaying season just proved that Samey is so much less interesting without interactions with Jasmine or Amy. Samey uttered the classic "Hey, Lindsay" line that she would be remembered for. She existed in this season to be fodder, and will probably be fodder next season too. Poor Maria and her English.

Dave


This Dave acts like TDPI never happened. Dave still goes after girls even though he previously attempted to kill one, he likes Heather for unexplained reasons, and he's still trying to be on Sky's good side. He also hates people like Cameron and Tyler for completely unexplained reasons. He's addicted to forming alliances publicly for everyone to see for unexplained reasons. He's always trying to befriend Cody for unexplained reasons. Everything Dave says or does in this season is absolutely unjustifiable. If the real Dave was still in this season, I'd still hate him, but at least he'd be in character and be consistent. Dave was just unbearable to watch, and I hope he's like the version of himself next season that we all hate. Yeah, despite being first eliminated, he managed to be more interesting than three people higher than him on the list, but at least they didn't personally anger. And what's all this about playing guitar with Cody?!

Heather


Canon-wise, Heather is my favorite female contestant. Here, she's pretty low. Her roleplayer TDPIScarlett wasn't really one to speak too often. This is a shame because Heather can be interesting in any season with the right interactions. I thought she lasted way too long. Merging at 10 was a mistake because both teams had five players. Heather should have been eliminated before the merge. I hope she speaks more next season.

Gwen


I don't even know how you can roleplay as Gwen. In the canon series, her characterization is so inconsistent and all over the place. But at least talk. Like Heather, Gwen should not have merged. I can't even remember anything she did besides argue with Courtney. I remember her being in this season less than Samey.

Scarlett


Practically the same reasons as Heather and Gwen. Canon-wise, Scarlett is a phenomenal character. She's evil and cunning, and could've easily been this season's antagonist. Here, she barely speaks. She's higher than Heather mostly cause I can remember something that Scarlett did. But all I remember about Scarlett is that she scolds her team whenever they lose, she's judgemental of everyone, and lost in a tiebreaker against Lindsay. And it was never really brought up why Scarlett was brought back to the competition after she tried murdering five people the first time she competed.

Dawn


So, Dawn, what happened with her in this season? She was unnecessary cruel to people, especially Scott, her romance with Noah came out of nowhere, and she just shouldn't be a player you should be afraid of. I would have actually accepted Dawn being silent this season because the point of her character is to be mysterious. She was meaner than Heather, or Scarlett. Even though it was interesting to see Dawn be such a cruel and vindictive person, it was pretty OOC.

Clue for Number 9: Loves to eat...