User blog comment:DuncanRocks123/Duncan Season 1 vs Duncan Season 2/@comment-31556666-20140926162017

Neither really. The thing about Duncan's character is that he's an anti-hero, meaning he's pretty much an antagonistic hero. He's middle ground. Unfortunately, you only have put his character in one direction for each season. He has more depth than just being a mean guy, while also having more depth than just being a nice guy.