User blog comment:LlewellynIsAwesome!/Antagonists!/@comment-31556666-20141119182317

Scott caused more than Ezekiel's (1st), Jo's, and Katie's eliminations. He was technically also responsible for Sierra's and Ella's since they were voted off because the team felt bad for Scott ever since certain members voted off Courtney, including Ella and Sierra. Therefore, Scott is responsible for those eliminations.

Scott attempted to drive a wedge between the girls by throwing a rock at Sky and swearing that it was Samey. Then afterwards Scott was indirectly responsible for Sky's elimination since she quit in his place.

Scott was technically responsible for Samey's elimination. She was the leader of a girl's alliance that was equal to the guy's. Knowing this, Scott convinced his fellow alliance members to vote for Samey, resulting in a 3-3 tie. Since Scott also beat Samey in this tiebreaker and came up with the idea to vote her off, he was also responsible for her elimination.

I don't know whether or not Lindsay counts.

I think Scott should objectively considered the best antagonist of the RP for other reasons though. One thing about him is that fellow contestants actually don't expect him to strike on them. He presents himself as this really dumb guy, making him underestimated, saving him from votes while he drops other players from the game. Sure. Tyler managed to get rid of many players, but Scott even lasted longer in the season where he was the main antagonist. Scott was only beaten by someone with equal antagonist qualities (Duncan). To add to that, Scott's plan was successful. He got to the Final 2 with the very person he was planning to get to the Final 2. Every single one of Scott's plans were successful, and he was only beaten by Duncan's skill in the end of it all. And really, I don't see much other flaws with his antagonism besides his intelligence (which, like I said, actually benefits him somewhat). I think all the other antagonists have some sort of noticeable flaws.

I mean, I guess Alejandro was okay. It's in-character for him to have smart plans. The problem came once it came to whether Alejandro wanted to eliminate Bridgette or Geoff first, and he goes and eliminates Bridgette. If I was Alejandro, I would've eliminated Geoff. He was clearly a bigger problem in Alejandro's grand plan of trying to take the money. Geoff, at all costs, wanted to get rid of Alejandro first chance he got. Since Geoff had then won immunity in London the Ripper, Alejandro was voted off because he was way more of a threat since Geoff made this obvious to everyone. If Alejandro kept Bridgette, he could've possibly won the season. Bridgette, despite hating Alejandro, fell for his charm easily. He could've used this to his advantage by manipulating her. That certainly wouldn't have worked on Geoff. Alejandro: Good villain, occasional poor planning.

Heather. Could've eliminated Lindsay, but it's hard to give Heather much good credit when Katie of all people betrays her. Heather also made herself an easy target by reading Sky's diary.

Noah was an okay villain I suppose. Unfortunately, he was an open target ever since S2 began due to his past performances in S1. He was an even more open target once people figured out he voted off Tyler. What Noah needed to do was get more people on his side. Had he done that, he would've done better.

Sadie is missed potential. End of story. I hope S4 does more for her. "Sadie and Scott" page coming sooooon.

Sugar was a bad villain. Eliminating Courtney who she could've used to her advantage since Courtney was trying to regain Scott's trust, and then kind of abandoning her private alliance with Heather and Scott.

Tyler is my 2nd favorite villain, but I can't really call him one, since, as already stated, he'll initially act like Gwen did when she was put on the villains team. Confused and stressed. Once he does get the antagonist label due to some convincing from a fellow villain (coughScottcough), I'm sure he can be a full-fledged one. At the moment, he's been an okay villain, but his performance in S2 heavily hindered him since he was taken down easily by Noah, which demonstrated Tyler's gullibility as the canon series already suggested with his friendship with Alejandro.

That's why Scott's been my favorite. He's been the least flawed.