User blog comment:DerpyandDawn/Character Of The Week - Voting Process/@comment-31556666-20150616095719

It's not even close between these three. Sky began okay in RTTI, if a little overrated and was fantastic in WW. But once AST2 came along, she was starting to really bore me with her lack of doing much combined with getting to the F3. She's good in AN but she's hindered by the fact that at this point, she is in screenhogger territory.

Duncan was peachy in RTTI and didn't do much like more than half the cast. I was neutral to him though since he was harmless. He was amazing in WW, if a little overrated. He had a dumb relationship with Sky that made zero sense for his character but aside from that, he was pretty good. But Duncan is flat-out unbearable in TB. 90% of his dialogue can be summed up towards "Samey", which is another illogical relationship for Duncan to have. But the fact that all of his lines are him spewing how much he loves Samey is not only gross and out-of-character, but completely overused. For once in AST2, I wanted him to last longer as he was the only real interesting conflict on Brawns. It's a shame he went because he's neutral for me for not lasting long and had he switched placings with say, Lightning, then Duncan would definitely be one of my favorites.

Amy isn't a perfect character either, but I prefer her to Duncan and Sky. ATW was a great season for her since she was completely original and diverse from her canon form and had more than one arc to go along with it. If I had one complaint, it would be that she kind of victimized herself too often and it got tiresome after a while. Otherwise, she was great. Amy was the worst female in TB for me though. She had little to no lines, and her weirdest moment was when she stalked Scott throughout an entire episode. There was no plot from her and she went at the right time. She was also the worst female in AST2 for me as well. She had barely any lines and her conflict with Anne Maria was more vocal for Anne Maria's point of view anyways. Amy exited in a horrible and out-of-character way, insulting her sister before she left. She's been better in AN, but is either in the background or right at the forefront. So...

I wish there was a harder choice.